Amenity Roofing & Siding

Roof Repair vs. Replacement? Making the Right Decision for Your Home

roof repair vs replacement

Your home’s roof is one of its most important, though often overlooked, features. A good-quality roof provides protection from the elements and ensures the safety and comfort of your family. It also plays a role in energy efficiency, deterring pests, and enhancing curb appeal.

Over time, roofs can deteriorate due to various factors such as age, weather conditions, and regular wear and tear. When faced with roofing issues, homeowners often find themselves contemplating whether to opt for roof repair or replacement. If you are in this boat, this blog post is for you.

Here, we will look at roof repair vs replacement so you can make an informed decision for your home. Making the right decision requires careful consideration of several factors. This includes the extent of the damage, the roof age, your budget, and long-term goals.

Let’s get started and delve into the pros and cons of roof repair and replacement.

Average Roof Material Lifespans

First things first, it’s necessary to look at the average lifespan of the various roofing materials that homeowners use today. Outside of incidents that cause damage to a home, the age of the roof itself plays a leading role in determining whether repair or replacement is the smartest option.

Different roof materials have varying lifespans based on their quality, installation, maintenance, and local climate conditions. Below are the average lifespans for some common roof materials.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in the United States. The primary reason they are so popular is their cost, as well as their general reliability. However, they are not the very best choice when it comes to longevity.

Typically, asphalt shingles have a lifespan of between 15 and 30 years. However, higher-quality shingles can last up to 50 years with proper maintenance.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is generally seen as a more premium option than asphalt shingles. It costs more and is more durable and resistant to extreme weather conditions. It also requires minimal maintenance throughout its lifetime.

Metal roofs, such as steel or aluminum, have an average lifespan of 40 to 70 years.

Wood Shingles or Shakes

Wood shingles have an average lifespan of 20 to 40 years. With this roofing material, regular maintenance can help extend its lifespan. This is a good option for people who are environmentally conscious.

Clay or Concrete Tiles

Clay or concrete tiles have a long lifespan, ranging from 50 to over 100 years. Pros here include that they are highly durable, fire-resistant, and require little maintenance during their lifespan.


When it comes to roof material longevity, slate is the clear winner. These roofs are known for their exceptional longevity, often lasting 75 to well over 100 years. Proper installation and periodic maintenance can ensure their extended lifespan.

Synthetic Roofing Materials

Synthetic roofing materials include options such as synthetic slate or composite shingles. Depending on the specific material and quality, they typically have a lifespan ranging from 30 to 50 years.

The bottom line here is that while roofs are durable features of our homes, they won’t last forever. It’s important to know which material your roof consists of and when the roof was installed. If your roof is nearing the end of its expected lifespan, replacement is generally a better option than repair.

The Case for Roof Repair

Now that we better understand the average lifespan of roofing materials, let’s look at the case for roof repair. Put simply, roof repair involves addressing specific issues and damages without replacing the entire roof.

It is typically suitable when any roof damage is localized and the overall condition of the roof is still relatively good. As noted above, repair is an option when the roofing material is not close to the end of its expected lifespan. Below are some key points to consider when opting for roof repair.


The average cost of replacing a roof in the United States is $8,600 (based on an average price range of $5,601 to $11,729). The average cost, on the other hand, of repairing a roof is a little under $1,000.

As such, repairing your roof is generally more cost-effective than a full replacement. By fixing the problem areas, you can extend the lifespan of your roof and postpone the need for a complete overhaul.


Roof repair projects are usually less time-consuming than replacements. Depending on the scale of the repair, your roofing contractor can complete the work in a matter of days, minimizing disruption to your daily routine.

Generally, the duration of a roof repair project depends on several factors. These include:

  • The extent of the damage
  • Accessibility of the affected area
  • The expertise of the roofing contractor

For minor repairs, such as fixing a few missing shingles or sealing a small leak, the job can often be completed within a day or two. Even for more significant repairs, such as repairing a larger section of the roof, the timeframe is typically shorter compared to a full roof replacement.

Localized Damage

If the damage is confined to a specific area, such as a few missing shingles or a small leak, repair is often the best course of action. Here at Amenity Roofing & Siding, our team can identify the problem areas and provide targeted solutions, saving you time and money.


As we have noted above, regular maintenance of a roof helps to extend its lifespan. Regular maintenance and timely repairs can help prevent small issues from escalating into larger, more costly problems. By addressing minor damages promptly, you can ensure the longevity of your roof.

The Case for Roof Replacement

Now it’s time to make the case for roof replacement. Depending on the specific type of material used, homeowners may only have to oversee roof replacement once or twice in their lifetimes.

Roof replacement involves removing the existing roof entirely and installing a new one. There are a number of instances when this option is considered best. These include when the roof has reached the end of its lifespan, sustained extensive damage, or requires frequent repairs.

When contemplating a roof replacement, it’s important to consider the following factors.

Age of the Roof

As noted above, you should know the material used on your roof and when it was installed. This allows you to determine the best time to replace your roof based on the expected lifespan.

As a roof nears the end of its expected lifespan, you may start to notice recurring issues that require repair. This is generally a good sign that the best course of action is to schedule a full roof replacement.

Extensive Damage

If the damage to your roof is widespread, with multiple leaks, sagging areas, or rotting, a replacement may be necessary. In such cases, repairing individual sections might not effectively address the underlying problems.

It’s best to speak to an experienced roofing team, such as Amenity Roofing & Siding, to determine the extent of damage and whether repair or replacement is recommended.

Energy Efficiency

We noted in the introduction that roofs play an important role in energy efficiency within homes. A new roof presents an opportunity to improve your home’s energy efficiency.

Modern roofing materials offer better insulation and ventilation, leading to reduced energy consumption and lower utility bills in the long run.

Curb Appeal

Also noted in the introduction was the role that roofs play in terms of curb appeal. A roof replacement can dramatically enhance the curb appeal of your home, which also helps to boost its overall value. Opting for a new roof allows you to select a roofing material, style, and color that better matches your taste.

Budget Considerations

Above, we highlighted the average cost of replacing and repairing a roof. While repairs are generally more affordable in the short term, it’s essential to consider long-term costs. For example, if your roof is older and requires frequent repairs, the cumulative expenses might exceed the cost of a replacement.

If you do decide on roof replacement, it’s important to select a roofing material that matches your available budget. Below, we will highlight the average cost of different roofing materials.

Asphalt Shingles

We have highlighted how asphalt shingles are popular among U.S. homeowners due to their affordability. The price varies based on the quality of the shingles, the brand, and any additional features such as impact resistance or energy efficiency.

Generally, the cost of asphalt shingles per square foot in the U.S. is $4.25 to $4.95 (including installation). For premium asphalt shingles, the cost can rise to up to $8.25. 

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs come in a wide range of options, including steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. The specific cost depends on the type of metal, finish, and complexity of installation. For example, aluminum roofs cost between $4.50 and $8.25 per square foot.

Wood Shingles or Shakes

Wood shingles or shakes provide a natural and traditional look. However, they are generally more expensive than asphalt shingles. Depending on the type of wood, the cost per square foot is between $8 and $14.30.

Clay or Concrete Tiles

Both clay and concrete tiles tend to be more expensive than most other options. Clay, for example, generally costs between $12 and $24.75 per square foot. Concrete tiles, meanwhile, cost between $11 and $19.80 per square foot.


Slate is a premium roofing choice that, as we have highlighted, has a very long lifespan. Thanks to this and its high-end appearance, it is one of the most expensive roofing materials.

The exact price varies based on the quality, color, size, and thickness of the slate. Homeowners can expect to pay between $12 and $22 per square foot.

It’s important to note that these are average costs and can vary depending on specific project requirements. Here at Amenity Roofing & Siding, we will provide you with a free quote based on an on-site assessment.

Consider the Environmental Impact

More than ever before, homeowners are considering the environmental impact of their actions. As such, when deciding between roof repair and replacement, it’s crucial to consider the environmental impact of your choice.

The first thing to say is that repairing your existing roof is generally more environmentally friendly compared to a full replacement. By opting for repair, you’re minimizing the amount of waste generated and reducing the demand for new roofing materials.

Roof replacement, on the other hand, presents an opportunity to choose more sustainable materials. As noted above, it can also help to improve the energy efficiency of your home. 

Many modern roofing materials offer eco-friendly options, such as recycled content, renewable resources, and improved insulation properties. For instance, metal roofs are often made from recycled materials and can be recycled again at the end of their lifespan.

If your current roof is nearing the end of its lifespan or lacks energy-efficient features, a replacement using sustainable materials may be a worthwhile investment.

Ultimately, whether you choose roof repair or replacement, there are opportunities to make eco-friendly choices and reduce your carbon footprint.

The Bottom Line: Roof Repair vs Replacement

When it comes to roof repair vs. replacement, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Each situation is unique, and the right choice depends on various factors, such as the age of your roof and your available budget.

The bottom line is that consulting with a professional roofing contractor will provide you with the expertise and guidance necessary to make an informed decision.

Here in Montgomery, IL and surrounding areas, your premier choice for roof repair and replacement is Amenity Roofing & Siding. We have more than 20 years of combined industry experience to draw on. To get started, schedule your free estimate or property inspection today.


Our Service Areas

Scroll to Top

How can we help you?

Lets Get Your FREE Estimate!

* Required
Your message was sent!
Thank You. We will call you within 24 hours, or the next business day.

Your local Montgomery, Plainfield, Aurora & Naperville, IL Roofing Contractor.

Ready to get your free estimate?

Your local Licensed Public Adjustor Roofing Contractor.

Do you want your free estimate?