Amenity Roofing & Siding

Roof Repair Vs. Replacement: Which Should You Choose?

Roof repair

Have you noticed a leak in your roof? Perhaps you have spotted a few missing shingles. The roof on your home is a critical structure to maintain, and if you fail to do so, that can cause numerous risks to its structural integrity. It can also make your living environment unhealthy. Yet, the question many people have is this one. Should you get a roof repair or replacement?

A roof repair can usually be done quickly by a trained professional. It may be a fast and immediate solution, depending on the overall condition of the roof itself. At the same time, if the damage is significant and the problem could happen again, replacement may be a better option for you.

To learn which is best in your case, it is best to have a licensed and insured technician out to your home to inspect and provide recommendations for you. With roofing experts like those at Amenity Roofing available to you, this process does not have to be a challenge. It can be eye-opening for you, though.

Determine the Structural Damage to the Roof

The first thing you need to consider is the structural well-being of the roof and just how well it can hold up. The structure of the roof is often the wood support system that is under the shingles. This area is critical to maintaining the overall health of your roof. If it is wet, damaged, broken, or otherwise in poor condition, it’s necessary to remove and replace it.

Remember that any time the interior of your home has water damage, there is a risk of mold growth. That can put your home’s overall health at risk. If an inspection reveals that the structure has been compromised, work with a roofing team for replacement, as a roof repair may not fully address the issue.

When Can Your Roof Just Be Repaired?

Here is the good news for many homeowners. Roof repair is often an option and can be an easy solution for getting your property secure and safe. This depends on the situation, but if the problem is very localized or can be fixed by a licensed roofing technician quickly, that could be the route to take.

A good example of this is a missing single or a contained leak. In those cases, the roofing company can remove the damaged area and replace it with a new layer of shingles. Patching areas of leaks around flashing may also be an option. There are numerous roof repair strategies to handle those types of problems. When the problem is very local, a roof repair may be a viable solution.

What Other Factors Should You Consider When Making the Roof Repair vs Replacement Decision?

There is certainly a lot to think about when trying to determine if you should get a new roof or just make repairs. Most of the time, a roof inspection will pinpoint the answer for you. There are a few more things to consider before making that decision, though.

How Old Is the Roof?

If your roof is more than 20 years old, roof replacement is likely in the near future, no matter what. This is dependent on the type of materials you have, of course. However, a roof repair on an old roof will prolong it for a short period of time. You will still need to have it replaced within the coming years, which may mean doing it now could save you money by avoiding additional repair calls.

Is There Damage That’s Covered by the Insurance Company?

Your insurance policy may offer coverage for roof replacement or roof repair if you have storm-related damage or damage that otherwise falls under your specific policy guidelines. If you do have insurance coverage, the insurance company will determine if it will cover the full replacement of the roof or just repairs. That is often based on the extensiveness of the damage itself. Start here and let your roofing company help you provide evidence of the damage present.

What Type of Damage Is Present on the Roof?

Some types of damage are more problematic than others. Is your roof missing numerous shingles in various locations? Do you have cracked or even curled-up shingles in various spots? You may also have a large amount of granules located in the downspouts and gutters. These are all signs that the roof has significant damage. You may do better to have it replaced at this point. 

What Are Your Energy Costs?

Though you may not want to replace your roof just because you want lower energy bills, if it is old and getting close to that point, and your energy costs are increasing, consider it. The fact is you may find that a new roof could pay for itself over time. That’s especially true if your heating and cooling costs are going up each year. New roofing solutions can help to reduce the cost significantly.

Do You Need To Get Roofing Repairs Often?

Every time you have a leak, a missing shingle, or an area of damage to the roof, you should have it inspected and repaired. If you find you are doing this often, perhaps even more than once a season, it may be time to consider the value of replacing your roof instead. Roof replacement can save you a significant amount of money in these situations.

Get an estimate and find out

If you are still unsure which is the best route for you, why not get an estimate for a new roof and the roof repair? You can have a licensed roofer out to inspect the roof and offer insight into its overall health and condition. Then, they can give you an estimate of the cost of actually replacing the roof. Ask for the cost just to repair the damage present. Then, make a decision based on the financial benefits of roof repair or replacement. 

You Should Not Have to Make That Decision on Your Own

Now is a good time to schedule an estimate for your roofing repair needs. You can do that by contacting our skilled professionals at Amenity Roofing & Siding in Montgomery, IL, to schedule one. Ask from the start if you are better off with a roof repair vs replacement, and find out which route could help you save money and time in the future. Our team is committed to providing fair rates on a wide range of roofing solutions. Call 630-636-9954 now to schedule an estimate.


Our Service Areas

Scroll to Top

How can we help you?

Lets Get Your FREE Estimate!

* Required
Your message was sent!
Thank You. We will call you within 24 hours, or the next business day.

Your local Montgomery, Plainfield, Aurora & Naperville, IL Roofing Contractor.

Ready to get your free estimate?

Your local Licensed Public Adjustor Roofing Contractor.

Do you want your free estimate?